[F]ar and away of Montreal's best record.

Pitchfork

a masterpiece of an album... Every song on this release is a legend.

Rebelation Zine

They successfully and continually find new ways to push the envelope without over doing it by creating beautiful harmonies and theatrical song breakdowns with multiple time signatures.

Last Life Media

As it turns out, there's only one word that can truly describe Kevin Barnes and of Montreal: brilliant.

Wordsmith

Their perfect blend of maturity, immaturity, and creativity shines through on the album.

The Tufts Daily

A powerful musical statement that will floor the band's old fans and certainly catch newcomers and past naysayers off guard.

Lost at Sea

There is no way any critic or music lover will be able to point out a negative aspect to this record. It's impossible.

AbsolutePunk

Impeccably arranged and produced, and, most importantly, it's a whole lot of fun.

Bass Head Media

The best pop-album an indie-fan could wish for - challenging but still simplistic enough to be immediately enjoyable.

The National Student

Satanic Panic In The Attic opened my eyes to an indie rock band with an interesting dimension that distinguishes them in this crowded rock scene.

PunkInternational